Norway could send its own citizens to prison for up to three years if they trade with Israeli communities in Judea and Samaria. That is the core of a proposal now under public consultation in Oslo, with responses due Sept. 19. The measure has not been enacted.

The draft law, put forward by Norway’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, would bar Norwegian people and companies from importing goods made in Israeli settlements in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem. It would also block exports to those communities. Beyond goods, it would restrict some real estate deals, construction and engineering services tied to property there, and purchases of businesses headquartered and producing in the settlements.

Intentional violations could bring fines, up to three years behind bars, or both. Even negligent violations could carry fines and up to six months in prison, according to the Foreign Ministry’s consultation document. The proposal would also let Norway prosecute qualifying conduct that happens outside its borders, even if the same act is legal under local law.

Foreign Minister Espen Barth Eide has said the government expects parliament, the Storting, to take up the legislation this fall. He told Norway’s public broadcaster NRK that the aim is to stop commercial activity that helps maintain Israeli communities beyond the pre-1967 lines. The document says humanitarian work would be exempt, as would transactions the government judges to have sufficient Palestinian ties and not to support building or expanding Israeli communities.

Critics say the plan singles out Jews. The Israeli Embassy in Oslo called the proposal hostile and part of what it described as biased anti-Israel activism. Some Israeli residents in Norway warned it could stoke anxiety among Jews. One critic told Fox News the bill rests on a misguided view of the conflict and, at its core, is deeply racist toward Jews.

The consultation text does not frame the measure as targeting Jews. It frames the target as commercial activity that sustains settlements beyond the 1967 lines. Officials say exemptions would be judged by who benefits and whether the activity contributes to construction, expansion, or maintenance of an Israeli community.

This is not happening in a vacuum. Last week, 12 Western states said they would impose or support national restrictions on trade in goods from Israeli settlements: Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Iceland, Ireland, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, and the United Kingdom. Britain’s Foreign Secretary told Parliament that London would introduce an import ban on goods from settlements within nine months, while continuing to support trade with Israel inside the Green Line. France and Canada have also announced bans on settlement goods.

Israel has pushed back hard. After the wave of announcements, Israeli officials threatened embassy closures and ordered Britain’s East Jerusalem consulate shut. In June, five countries, including Norway, coordinated sanctions on Israeli figures and groups they said enable settler violence in Judea and Samaria. That round included asset freezes and travel bans.

Here is the detour that matters. Trade with these communities is not huge. The Foreign Minister himself noted that wine and some agricultural products are among the goods involved. The point of the law is not to slam a massive economic door. It is to draw a bright line around activity that these governments say violates international law. Supporters argue it aligns Norway with that view and protects Palestinian commerce and humanitarian aid. Opponents argue it criminalizes ordinary business and, in effect, marks Jews.

The proposal would apply to both individuals and companies. Authorities could seize prohibited goods. The measure would waive the usual double criminality rule, so a Norwegian could face prosecution at home for settlement-related transactions even when the activity is legal where it occurred. That is a sharp tool.

Norwegian Jewish leaders have called the plan deeply troubling and dangerous. They say it could create real anxiety among Jews living in Norway. The consultation period closes Saturday. After that, the government will decide whether to send the bill to parliament.

So where does this leave a reader who just wants the facts straight? Norway has proposed a trade ban on Israeli settlements in Judea and Samaria that could carry prison time. Critics say the proposed trade ban effectively singles out Jews. The text says it targets settlement commerce, not Jews. The dispute over what the law does in practice is unresolved.

And then there is the quiet part. If this passes, a Norwegian who knowingly sells construction services to a business in a settlement, or buys a stake in a company based there, could be looking at a criminal case at home. That is a concrete consequence. It is also a signal that a group of Western states now treats settlement trade as beyond the pale. Whether that signal helps or harms, and whether it crosses into discrimination, is the fight still underway in Oslo.

Explore: Executive Branch